Advertisement
///

Baltimore County Appeals Board Rejects County Bid to Revisit Environmental Penalty Ruling

1 min read

The Baltimore County Board of Appeals on Nov. 12 agreed to deny the county’s request to reconsider its ruling in an environmental enforcement case, after finding the county had not shown that a property owner must post security covering the full $30,000 penalty.

The Case

The matter, case CBA-27-001, involves 11053 Bowerman LLC and 11049 Bowerman, LLC. An administrative law judge found in favor of the county and imposed a $30,000 fine, with $25,000 of it suspended on the condition that the respondents make required repairs to the property.

The respondents appealed. The board held a hearing Aug. 27 and issued an opinion Sept. 11 finding the appeal without merit. One member said the board had intended that written opinion to be definitive.

Advertisement

The Security Dispute

At the original hearing, the county moved to dismiss the appeal. It argued the appellant had not posted security in the full amount of the civil penalty, as the county code requires for this type of appeal. The board said it did not have enough information to rule on that point and did not grant the motion. It reviewed the case on its merits and sided with the county.

The county then asked the board to reconsider the security question. The disagreement comes down to what the code’s reference to the amount of the civil penalty covers. The county reads it as the full $30,000. The appellant reads it as the $5,000 that is not suspended and was due outright.

Why the Board Said No

The three board members said they found no case law or statutory analysis supporting the county’s reading, either in their own research or in what the county filed. One member noted that the few relevant cases found were old, and that federal appeal rules, which treat bond amounts more flexibly, are not directly comparable to the county code.

Advertisement

Members said the burden is on the party seeking reconsideration, and that the county had not met it. They added that the county’s position rested only on the text of the code, which does not itself define the disputed phrase. They also pointed out that the code gives the county other ways to collect a penalty if repairs are not made, including placing a lien on the property and pursuing the owner in a civil action. One member said the county did not need to win on an additional basis in this matter.

The board also noted that the appellant had been given until mid-November to complete the required repairs, and that the status of that work was unknown at the hearing. If the repairs are made, the owner owes only the $5,000 that was not suspended.

What’s Next

The board agreed to deny the county’s motion for reconsideration and said it would issue a written order. The case then moves on in its normal course. Because the written order had not been issued by the end of the hearing, the exact language of the board’s decision on the security question remains to be seen.

Advertisement
Advertisement

TANTV STAFF

TANTV Staff is the editorial team at TANTV News, an independent media organization serving the Washington, D.C. metro area and beyond. TANTV provides trusted, community-centered journalism covering local government, economy, immigration, culture, and social justice issues across the DMV region.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.